I think I can count on two fingers the number of times that peer review has been positive. I have found it to be almost universally territorial, and not very collegial. I think ideally, it could be formative in the way as you described, but I’ve almost never seen it actually practiced that way.
I think I can count on two fingers the number of times that peer review has been positive. I have found it to be almost universally territorial, and not very collegial. I think ideally, it could be formative in the way as you described, but I’ve almost never seen it actually practiced that way.